1837 – 1851  Benjamin T. Congdon

1851 – 1859  Benjamin K. Sayer

1859 – 1883  Charles C. Sayer

1883 – 1903  George B. Richmond

1903 – 1922  Albert B. Collins

1922 – 1935 James P. McCrohan

1935 – 1957 Lawerence W. Caton

1957 – 1969 Joseph A. Sylvia

1969 – 1993 John Gomes

1993 – 2000 James L. Henry

2000 – 2017 J. Mark Treadup

2017 – 2021 Frederick M. Kalisz, Jr. 

2021 – present Sherrilynn M. Mello